[#Cloud #クラウド] SaaSストレージ比較: Google DocsとWindows Azure

Windows AzureとGoogleのストレージサービスの比較

Azureが正式にサービスを開始したのが2月の頭、さらにGoogle Docsがファイル形式の限定をはずした事をきっかけに、クラウドストレージのサービスが活発かいてきている。

下記は、Gladinet社というクラウドストレージベンダーがAzureとGoogleの2つを比較した記事。 

結果としては然程違いは無い、と言いながらも、簡易ユーザはGoogle、カスタマイズを含めたユースケースはAzure、という提言をしている。 

1. Price

Google’s storage cost = 25c / Gigabyte / year = 2c / Gigabyte / month. There is no additional transfer cost.

image

Windows Azure’s storage cost is at 15c / Gigabyte / month. There is additional cost for transfer data in and out.

image

Note: Google storage is clearly cheaper, about 10 times cheaper.

2. Speed

We will use Gladinet Cloud Desktop to map both in a virtual drive in Windows Explorer and compare the time it takes to complete a drag & drop upload task of each.

image

File Size: 9.3M

Azure Storage Upload: 43 seconds => 216 Kbytes/s

Google Docs Upload: 68 seconds => 136 Kbytes/s

Azure Storage is faster to upload. However, the 136 Kbytes/s is very decent upload speed too. The speed could also vary depending on whether you are close to a Google data center or a Microsoft Azure data center or which one is busier or less.

3. Usability & Tools

Google Storage is shared between Gmail, Picasa Web Albums and Google Docs,  all of which have web interfaces to use and share with friends. For the desktop PC UI interface, you have client side GUI tools such as Google Picasa, Gladinet Cloud Desktop or Memeo Connect to connect your Google Storage account directly into your Desktop PC.

Azure on the other hand, is more geared toward developers. You won’t be able to use Azure Storage until you write some code. You can use some 3rd parties’ tools to use Azure Storage, such as Azure Storage Explorer, Cloud Storage Studio, Azure MMC plug-in,  Gladinet and others.

Google Storage is more usable out of the box. However, Azure storage may have more tools available down the road.

Note: This may not be an apple-to-apple comparison in this aspect between Google Storage and Azure Storage. A better comparison may be between Google Storage and Windows Live SkyDrive when both have web interface.

4. Service Level Agreement

Google’s SLA is different for free user, Google Apps user and Google Apps Premier Edition user. Below is a glimpse of what is offered for the premier account users, which may not be applied to free users.

Google Apps SLA.

“During the Term of the applicable Google Apps Agreement, the Google Apps Covered Services web interface will be operational and available to Customer at least 99.9% of the time in any calendar month (the “Google Apps SLA”).”

Windows Azure SLA 
“For storage, we guarantee that at least 99.9% of the time we will successfully process correctly formatted requests that we receive to add, update, read and delete data. We also guarantee that your storage accounts will have connectivity to our Internet gateway.”

5. Developer Support

Google offers Google DATA Protocol for developers. Windows Azure offersAzure SDKs which integrates directly into Visual Studio.

It is much easier to program towards Windows Azure Storage with Visual Studio so you may see more tools and internet products built on top of Windows Azure further down the road.

However, if you are using PHP, Ruby or anything other than .NET, Azure SDK may not have  a big advantage over Google APIs.

 

Posted via email from Ippei’s @CloudNewsCenter info database

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: